Dueling Panini.

We dusted off the Griddler this week!

I just love that name. The Griddler. It holds a promise of fun and a tasty grilled sandwich. Or two.


We’d toted a cooler still full of food home from our ill-fated camping excursion. Turkey. Pesto. Tomatoes. That sounded like a tasty sammie to me, so out came the Griddler. Then, my creative juices started flowing and I pulled a few more items out of the fridge. An apple. Fig jam. A fat jalapeno. A couple of cheeses. I’m not sure how it happened, but before I knew it, we were in the middle of a PANINI DUEL.

P1070478 P1070479 P1070480P1070481 P1070482

Here’s how the magic happened. First, I crisped up some sliced pancetta in the oven. I literally almost stopped making dinner and simply dined on crispy pig and Pinot Grigio. Can you blame me?

P1070474 P1070475

Next, I brainstormed flavor combinations. For Panino #1, I landed on fig jam, turkey, brie, apples, and- knowing it would need a KICK to balance out the sweetness- jalapeno slices.

P1070483 P1070485

When making a sandwich with many layers of deliciousness, the order of the items becomes important. I placed the apple slices on the fig jam to help hold them in place, then added the turkey and jalapeno. I wanted the cheese to be the “glue” that held the other slice of bread to the sammie and melted in between everything else.

P1070486 P1070488

The Griddler is so easy to use. You simply plug it in and let it get hot, place your sammie inside, press down the lid, and leave it alone to grill!

P1070489 P1070491

In the meantime, I got started on Panino #2. This sammie was a little more traditional: turkey, pesto, pancetta, tomatoes, spinach, and the wild card– cheddar cheese. Cheddar and pesto didn’t seem to match in my head, but it’s what I had in the fridge!

P1070492 P1070493 P1070494

Again, the order of the layers was important- the pesto spread on one piece of bread, the cheese on the other side, and everything else in between. 

P1070495 P1070496 P1070497

When I’d finished constructing Panino #2, the first sammie was done! Hello, Lovely.

P1070499 P1070502 P1070504

Look at that melty brie and crisp bread! The Griddler compresses the sandwich as it grills, smooshing all of the wonderful ingredients together. You san see the layers of turkey, apple, and spicy jalapeno, the brie melted in between it all. Cue drool.

It didn’t take long for Panino #2 to crisp up. Again, the layers of ingredients were pressed into something magical, held together with melted cheddar. Yum!

P1070513 P1070515

John and I went splitsies, each taking one half from each Panino. It was time for the duel: Which Panino was better?


I started with a bite from the sweet and spicy Panino #1. The apple slices still had a slight crunch, which (along with the crunchy bread) added texture. The Brie melted wonderfully and mingled with the fig jam. The apple and fig were sweet, but the turkey added a salty bite. But the jewel on the crown was the jalapeno. The sweetness needed the spice for balance. Panino #1 was heavenly.

P1070521 P1070524

Panino #2 was entirely different. There was no sweetness. It was a mouthful of savory goodness– a sandwich you might see on various menus, but executed perfectly. The cheddar and pesto were delicious together, and the pancetta added a crispy layer in between the meat and veggies. Absolutely delicious.

P1070520 P1070526

John and I alternated bites of each Panino, describing the flavors and trying to decide which was better. The only things not completely amazing about these sandwiches are the photos of them! But we needed a winner. The verdict?

It was a tie. I held firm that the spicy-sweetness of Panino #1 was uniquely scrumptious, while John thought the texture and overall flavor of Panino #2 was better. We both agreed that adding pancetta to Panino #1 would have sent it over the top- another hit of salty crispness would have been perfection.

So the Great Panini Duel ended in a draw. They were both so delectable that I didn’t really care. But while we were happily munching away, John challenged me to a Panini grill-off. We’ll each come up with a fantastic grilled sammie and see whose is better! Stay tuned!

In the meantime, do yourself a favor and make these sandwiches. You tell me: Which one is better?

Sweet and Spicy Turkey Panini

You’ll need:

  • Good bread (we used rosemary sourdough)
  • Fig jam
  • Sliced green apple
  • Sliced turkey
  • Good quality brie cheese
  • Jalapeno slices
  • Crisp pancetta (if you know what’s good for you)

On one slice of bread, spread a light layer of fig jam. Place turkey slices over the fig, then the pancetta, then the apple slices, then plenty of jalapeno. Cover the other piece of bread with slices of brie (it’s easier to cut when it’s chilled). Place the cheese side on top of the fig side and grill in a Panini-maker until the bread is browned and the cheese is melted.

Pesto Pancetta Turkey Panini

You’ll need:

  • Good bread
  • Pesto (jarred or homemade)
  • Sliced turkey
  • Crisp pancetta
  • White cheddar cheese
  • Sliced tomatoes
  • Fresh spinach leaves

On one side of the bread, spread a light layer of pesto. Place the turkey slices over the pesto, then the pancetta, then the tomatoes, then the spinach. Cover the other piece of bread with sliced cheddar cheese. Place the cheese side on top of the pesto side and grill in a Panini-maker until the bread is browned and the cheese is melted.

You’re welcome.

**A list of recipes can be found on my FOOD BLISS link! Yum!**


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s